She comes in and sits down the way she always does. Her coat is still on, bag balanced on her knees, not quite ready to settle. She has a full life. She would be the first to say so. Good friendships, work that matters, a family that loves her. And yet she is here, in this chair, quietly devastated. She is thirty-eight and single, and somewhere along the way that fact became the only fact that seemed to count.

She is not broken, not avoidant, not self-sabotaging, not afraid of intimacy. She has done that work. She is, though she can’t name it yet, exhausted. Exhausted by the gap between the life she has and the life she was told she should want.

 

Even when she had a partner, she still sat here with the quiet, persistent sense that something is missing. That her partner cannot be everything; and somehow, that feels like evidence of failure.

This is where the questions begin. Not about the relationship itself, but about the story underneath it. Where did the idea come from that one person should be your primary emotional support, your best friend, your co-parent, your financial partner, your intellectual equal, and your most passionate lover… for the rest of your life?

That story has a name: amatonormativity.

What We’re Actually Talking About

The term was coined by philosopher Elizabeth Brake to describe the cultural assumption that romantic partnership is not just one good way to organize a life, but the way. ¹ The endpoint. The proof that you have arrived. Everything else, deep friendship, community, chosen family, meaningful solitude, gets quietly demoted in its presence.

You probably didn’t sign up for this script, but you have been living inside it anyway. Most of us have. It is not announced. It does not arrive as an instruction. It arrives as a feeling, a low-grade wrongness when your life does not match the image. A sense of falling behind in a race that you don’t remember entering.

It Is Everywhere, Once You See It

Look at the media you consume. Nearly every narrative arc bends toward romantic resolution. The protagonist finds love and the story ends, as if life begins at the altar and everything before was just prologue. The crisis is almost always relational, and the resolution is usually a person.

Scroll through a dating app and notice the language. My person. My other half. Looking for my partner in crime. The framing is scarcity and completion, as if you are, right now, only half of something. As if the app is not a place to meet people but a place to become whole. Sit with that for a second, let it settle in your body. You are constantly being sold the idea that you are not whole without “the one.” Even though people are making different choices, it is still very much the water we swim in.

Watch how the people around you talk about their relationships. Notice how a Friday night alone reads as loneliness, but a Friday night with a partner reads as thriving, even if the quality of those two evenings is identical. Even if the Friday night with your partner is not what you really wanted! Notice how easily friendships get deprioritized the moment a romantic relationship enters the picture. Notice how this reorganization happens without anyone saying it out loud, as if the hierarchy was always understood. This may not be universal, but how often has it happened to you? Have you ever been the culprit? I know I have.

Nobody handed you this script, but somewhere along the way, you learned it. If your life does not match it, if you are single longer than expected, or partnered but unfulfilled, or simply unwilling to organize your entire existence around one person, the script does not disappear. It just starts to feel like personal failure.

That is the thing about cultural norms. They do not announce themselves. They just make you feel like something is wrong with you when you do not conform.

So let’s name it. Because naming it is the first act of freedom.

Starting to Notice

Deconstruction does not have to be dramatic. It starts with attention.

  • Notice the hierarchy. When a friend cancels plans because their partner is suddenly free, notice the assumption underneath: Romantic relationships automatically outrank everything else. When you feel vaguely embarrassed about being single at an event, notice that too. You are not neurotic. You are responding to a very loud cultural message.
  • Notice the language. “My other half.” “Finding the one.” “Settling down.” These phrases are not neutral. They carry a whole worldview inside them. You do not have to reject them, but you can start to hear them differently. What does it mean to be half of something? Who decided you were incomplete?
  • Engage with your own story. Ask yourself honestly: what do you actually want from your relational life? Not what looks right, not what would make sense to explain at a family dinner, but what genuinely nourishes you? Some people deeply want a long-term romantic partnership. That is real and valid. But what does that imagined partnership truly give you? It is worth knowing whether that is your desire or an inherited expectation you have never examined. It is also worth noting if that’s the primary desire or something that is additive and where that belief came from.
  • Challenge your story about what is missing. If you are single, are you actually lonely, or have you absorbed the idea that singleness equals loneliness? If you are lonely, what other connections have you tried to build? If you are partnered and feeling like something is missing, are you actually unfulfilled, or have you absorbed the idea that one person should be able to fill everything? These are different questions with different answers. This is not to say that loneliness and unfullfilment aren’t actually real problems, but take a moment to examine if they are really what’s happening for you.
  • Engage with what is already there. Before looking for what the script says you are missing, look at what you already have. Friendships, community, chosen family, creative work, solitude that actually feels good. These are not consolation prizes. In many cultures and throughout most of human history, they were the point. ²

This is not about rejecting romance. It is about loosening the grip of a story that was never really yours to begin with.

More on where that story came from — and whose relationships it was never designed to include — in the next post. Check out Post 2 & Post 3!

 

Source Notes

  1. Brake, Elizabeth. Minimizing Marriage: Marriage, Morality, and the Law. Oxford University Press, 2012. Brake coins and defines amatonormativity as the assumption that a central, exclusive, amorous relationship is a universal human goal. 
  2. hooks, bell. All About Love: New Visions. William Morrow, 2000. hooks dismantles romantic love as a salvation myth and argues for a broader, more intentional understanding of love as practice and community. 

Additional reading: Perel, Esther. Mating in Captivity: Unlocking Erotic Intelligence. Harper, 2006. Perel’s work on the tension between intimacy and desire in long-term relationships provides useful context for the limits of the romantic partnership model, though she does not use the term amatonormativity directly.